Aizii Learn · AI Search

[← Back to Learn](https://aizii.ai/learn)

# Why does Gemini recommend my competitors

Gemini recommends your competitors because its answers are grounded in Google Search, and your competitor is stronger inside Google Search than you are. Google says its generative AI features on Google Search are rooted in its core Search ranking and quality systems, and that they use query fan-out, issuing multiple related searches across subtopics and data sources to build a response. A page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet to appear as a supporting link, and Google says there are no additional technical requirements and no special schema markup you need to add. If your competitor has more indexed pages answering the sub-questions behind the buyer question, and those pages rank in the core systems, Gemini cites them and not you.

One setting deserves its own warning, because it is the easiest to get wrong. Google-Extended is a robots.txt token, not a crawler. It controls whether content Google has already crawled may be used for Gemini training and grounding. Blocking it does not change your inclusion in Google Search or your ranking there, and it does not keep you out of AI Overviews or AI Mode, which run on the standard Search index. Blocking it only removes your content from Gemini's training and grounding data, which is the opposite of what you want when Gemini is recommending your competitors.

## Why Gemini skips your brand

Gemini's failure modes are its own:

1.  Your pages are not indexed, or not eligible to be shown with a snippet. Google states the eligibility rule plainly: a page must be indexed and snippet-eligible to appear as a supporting link. A noindex tag or a nosnippet directive takes the page out of the running entirely, no matter how good it is.
2.  Google-Extended is blocked by mistake. A privacy checklist somewhere told the team to block it, on the belief it stops Google from indexing the site. Google's own documentation says otherwise. The block quietly cuts you out of Gemini's grounding while your Search presence stays exactly where it was.
3.  Your competitor answers the fan-out and you do not. One buyer question becomes several related searches, and the answer draws on pages for each sub-question: the cost, the materials, who it is for, how it compares. Your competitor has a page for each one. You have a homepage and a product page.
4.  Your key facts are not in text form. Google lists making sure important content is available in textual form as a best practice for AI features. Product facts that only appear after JavaScript runs, or that live only inside images, give Google's systems less to retrieve and quote than a competitor page that states the same facts as text.
5.  Your local and product details are stale. Google lists checking that Merchant Center and Business Profile information is up to date as a best practice for AI features. A competitor whose product feed and business details are current gives Gemini verified facts to cite. A brand whose details are out of date gives it a reason to cite someone else.
6.  Your content is recycled, not first-hand. Google's optimization guide says content that is unique, compelling, and useful will likely influence a site's presence in generative AI search more than any other suggestion, and it calls out first-hand reviews and a unique point of view as the kind of content that stands out. A competitor page written from real experience wins over a page that restates what is already on the internet.

## Step 1: Run the prompt set and read the citations

Write ten to twenty prompts your buyers actually ask, including prompts that never name your brand, and run the same set in Gemini. Log three things for every prompt: whether your brand was named, whether a competitor was named, and which sources were cited. Run the set more than once, since a single run is a snapshot. The pattern across runs is the measure that matters: which kind of prompt cites your competitor, and from which sources.

## Step 2: Confirm your pages are indexed and snippet-eligible

Verify the site in Google Search Console and check that your key pages are indexed. Use URL Inspection for a live test of any page you suspect is blocked, and request a recrawl after you fix a robots.txt change. Check that no page you want cited carries a noindex tag or a nosnippet directive. A page outside the index cannot be cited, and a page that cannot show a snippet cannot appear as a supporting link. Google says crawling can take anywhere from several days to several months, depending on how often its systems determine a page needs to be refreshed, so a fix does not show up overnight.

## Step 3: Check Google-Extended, and Googlebot behind it

Open your robots.txt file and look for a Google-Extended group. If you find a block and want Gemini to recommend you, change it to an allow. Know what you are deciding: allowing it lets your content be used for Gemini training and grounding, while blocking it changes nothing about your Search inclusion or ranking. Do not look for Google-Extended in your server logs, since it has no user-agent string and never requests anything. Then confirm Googlebot itself can crawl: check robots.txt does not disallow it, check the edge for bot rules that challenge it, and confirm genuine requests with reverse and forward DNS. For the exact token and the log check, see our [guide to getting Gemini to recommend your brand](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/how-to-get-gemini-to-recommend-your-brand). For the full crawler reference, see our [robots.txt guide for AI search](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/how-to-write-robots-txt-for-ai-search).

## Step 4: Publish pages that answer the fan-out sub-questions

Take the prompts where your competitor was cited and list the sub-questions behind them: what it costs, what it is made of, who it is for, how it compares. Publish or improve a page for each real buyer question, in plain text, with the specific facts Gemini needs. Do not build a page for every possible related search as a long-term strategy; Google's own guidance calls that an ineffective approach and a way to violate its scaled content abuse policy when done to manipulate rankings. Build pages that answer real buyer questions, and let the same page serve the several related searches behind them.

## Step 5: Put key facts in text and keep your details current

Make sure price, specs, and availability appear as text on the product page, not only inside images or behind scripts. Check that your structured data matches the visible text on the page, since Google lists that as a best practice. Update your Merchant Center feed and your Business Profile so the product and business facts Gemini retrieves are current. Search your brand as a customer would: if the business panel is thin or stale, the local answers will be too.

## Step 6: Rerun the prompt set and log the change

After the fixes, rerun the same prompt set and log the citations again. The competitor does not disappear. What changes is that your brand starts appearing alongside them on the prompts your new pages answer. If a prompt still cites only the competitor, open the cited page and compare it with yours until you can see what it states that yours does not.

### Say you run a cookware brand

Say you run a cookware brand that sells a carbon steel pan. You run your prompt set in Gemini and find a competitor cited on nearly every buyer prompt that never names a brand, while you appear only when the prompt names you. You open the cited pages and find the competitor has a seasoning guide, a comparison page, and a page on pan sizes, each with current prices and first-hand notes from cooking with the pan. You have a product page and a homepage. Your product page states the price inside an image, your Business Profile still shows old hours, and a developer blocked Google-Extended in robots.txt while following a privacy checklist. You allow Google-Extended, put the price and specs in text on the page, update the Business Profile, and publish a seasoning guide and a comparison page with your current prices. You rerun the prompt set and log the citations. The competitor is still cited. Your brand starts appearing alongside them on the prompts your new pages answer.

### The fundamentals

These mechanics are shared across every engine and covered in full in their own guides:

-   •llms.txt: the file format, a complete sample, and per-platform publish steps, see our [guide to writing a good llms.txt file](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/how-to-write-a-good-llms-txt-file)
-   •Product schema: the JSON-LD markup that states price and availability in structured form, see our [product schema guide for AI search](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/how-to-add-product-schema-markup-for-ai-search)
-   •Every AI crawler in one reference table, see our [robots.txt guide for AI search](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/how-to-write-robots-txt-for-ai-search)

## What this guide does not cover

This guide covers why Gemini recommends your competitors and what to do about it. It does not cover getting cited in Google AI Overviews or AI Mode as a separate surface, which is a separate guide, or the transaction layer that turns a citation into a sale. It also does not cover monitoring, which is how you track whether the gap is closing across runs instead of guessing from a single check.

For the ChatGPT version of this playbook, see our [guide on why ChatGPT recommends your competitors](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/why-does-chatgpt-recommend-my-competitors). For the Perplexity version, see our [guide on why Perplexity recommends your competitors](https://aizii.ai/learn/ai-search/why-does-perplexity-recommend-my-competitors).

## Check your own brand now

Run the free scan. It takes seconds, no signup, and shows exactly where your site stands with every AI crawler today: aizii.ai/aeo-scan

[Run the free scan](https://aizii.ai/aeo-audit)

## Sources

-   Google Search Central, AI features and your website (specific): [https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features)
-   Google Search Central, Optimizing your website for generative AI features on Google Search (specific): [https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide)
-   Google common crawlers documentation (specific): [https://developers.google.com/crawling/docs/crawlers-fetchers/google-common-crawlers](https://developers.google.com/crawling/docs/crawlers-fetchers/google-common-crawlers)

Note: links marked specific point to the page that supports the claim in this guide. Links marked general docs point to the vendor's general docs section for that topic, not to a page that proves every step. Check the vendor docs for the current path before relying on a menu name or click path in this guide.
