Aizii Learn · AI Search
← Back to Learn

Do I need an AEO agency or can my SEO agency handle it

The short answer is that it depends on what your SEO agency can actually do, not on what it calls itself. Some SEO agencies can handle AEO well, because the foundation is the same: Google says optimizing for its generative AI features is still SEO, since those features run on the same ranking systems as classic search, and a page must be indexed and eligible to show in search with a snippet before it can appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode. An agency that keeps your pages indexed, fast, and full of clear answers already does half the AEO job. The other half is different work, and it is the half that decides the answer: crawler access for the AI search crawlers, the machine-readable files, structured data that states price and availability, and a routine that keeps facts current. If your agency can ship that work, you do not need a new agency. If it can only report on it, you do.

The question to ask is not whether the agency knows the term AEO. It is whether the agency has a developer who ships the fixes, a way to measure AI answers, and a scope that names the AEO work instead of folding it into the old SEO line items. This guide gives you the checks to run before you decide.

Where it goes wrong

Brands get this decision wrong in a few predictable ways, and each one costs a retainer cycle to undo.

  • The agency adds AEO to the invoice and changes nothing. The monthly deliverable stays a keyword report and a blog post, and the brand pays a premium for a word. If the scope does not name the new work, the new work is not happening.
  • The agency reports on AI visibility but cannot fix the site. A dashboard that shows your brand missing from AI answers is useful once. The twelfth month of the same dashboard is a subscription to bad news. Reporting without a shipper is not a service.
  • The agency treats AEO as a content job only. Content matters, and clear answers are the raw material of AI answers. But content on pages that crawlers cannot reach, or on pages with no structured data, is content the assistants never read. An agency with no technical owner will write more of it and change nothing.
  • The brand hires a second agency and the two fight over the site. Two agencies editing the same theme, the same robots.txt, and the same schema will overwrite each other, and neither will own the result. A split only works when the scopes are written so they do not overlap, with one owner per file and per page type.
  • The brand judges the agency on rankings alone. Rankings tell you where a page sits in a list. They say nothing about whether an assistant cites your brand, states your price correctly, or recommends a competitor instead. An agency judged only on rank will optimize only for rank, and the AEO work will quietly starve.
  • The brand hires on a pitch instead of a trial. A pitch deck proves the agency can sell. A single month of shipped fixes proves it can do the work. A trial month with a named fix list is cheaper than a six-month contract with a good deck.
  • The agency promises a place in AI answers. No vendor publishes a formula for what an assistant recommends, and no agency controls the answer. A promise of placement is a promise the agency cannot keep, and it is the clearest sign to walk away.

The steps

Step 1. Ask your SEO agency for the AEO fix list. The marketer asks the agency to produce, in writing, the AEO work it would do in the first month: which crawlers it would allow, which files it would publish, which pages would get structured data, and who would ship each item. A real answer names files, pages, and people. A vague answer names trends. If the agency cannot produce the list, it cannot do the work yet, whatever its website says.

Step 2. Check for a technical owner. The marketer asks who writes the code. AEO fixes land in robots.txt, llms.txt, theme templates, and structured data, and they need a developer with access to the theme and the server. If the agency's answer is that your developer will do it, the agency is selling advice, and you should price it as advice. If the agency has its own developer, ask for the name and for one fix they shipped for another brand, described in plain words.

Step 3. Check how the agency measures AI answers. The marketer asks how the agency will show, each month, whether the brand appears in AI answers and whether the facts in those answers are right. The answer should include a re-run scan, a check of the brand's core questions in the assistants, and a list of wrong answers corrected. A report that only shows rankings and traffic is an SEO report, and it cannot see the AEO work at all.

Step 4. Run a one-month trial on a named fix list. The marketer agrees on one month, one fix list taken from the free scan at aizii.ai/aeo-scan, and one price. The trial is the decision. If the fixes ship and the score moves, the agency can handle AEO, and the retainer can grow. If the month ends with a report and no shipped fixes, the agency cannot, and the trial cost you one month instead of six.

Step 5. Decide the shape: keep, split, or switch. The marketer makes the call on the trial evidence. Keep the SEO agency for all of it if the trial shipped the fixes. Split the work if the SEO agency is strong on content and the index but cannot ship the technical fixes: one agency owns content, the other owns the technical layer, and the scopes are written so they never touch the same file. Switch to an AEO agency if the SEO agency cannot do the work and will not learn it, and move the SEO foundation work with it, because the search index still feeds the AI features.

Step 6. Write the scope so the work cannot hide. The marketer writes the renewed scope with named deliverables: the files published, the pages marked up, the fixes shipped per month, and the monthly re-run scan. A scope that says the agency will improve AI visibility buys a feeling. A scope that says the agency will ship twelve fixes from the scan list buys work. Keep the renewal test from the trial: the retainer renews if the score moved and the fix list shrank.

Step 7. Keep the brand facts in one place. Whoever does the work, the marketer keeps a single source of truth for the brand facts: the product names, the prices, the availability, the policies, and the pages that state them. Two agencies, or an agency plus an in-house team, will drift apart without it. When the facts change, the source changes first, and every file and page follows from it.

The machine-readable piece

This is the Organization structured data a brand should have on its homepage, and it is a good test of any agency you are judging. It states who the brand is, in a form machines can read, and it links the brand's profiles with the sameAs property. An agency that cannot produce this block, or cannot explain what each field means, is not ready to own your structured data. Replace the placeholders with your own brand details, replacing yourdomain.com with your actual domain.

<script type="application/ld+json">
{
  "@context": "https://schema.org",
  "@type": "Organization",
  "name": "Cascade Pet Nutrition",
  "url": "https://[yourdomain.com]/",
  "description": "Cascade Pet Nutrition makes limited-ingredient dog food and treats, made in small batches and shipped across the country.",
  "sameAs": [
    "https://www.instagram.com/[your-brand]",
    "https://www.youtube.com/@[your-brand]",
    "https://www.reddit.com/r/[your-brand]/"
  ]
}
</script>

Check the block with the rich results test Google documents, and confirm the page shows the same facts a shopper sees: the same name, the same description, the same links. Structured data that says one thing while the page says another teaches a reader to distrust both. Do not add a field, a profile, or a value you cannot verify against the live site.

What it looks like when it works

When the decision is right, the monthly meeting changes shape. The agency shows fixes shipped, the score moving, and wrong answers corrected, and the brand asks about the next fixes, not about whether the work is happening. The SEO foundation keeps running underneath, because the search index still feeds the AI features, and the AEO work builds on it instead of replacing it.

Say you run a pet food brand on a monthly SEO retainer, and your brand rarely appears in AI answers for its core questions. You ask the agency for the AEO fix list, and it comes back with named files, named pages, and a developer who will ship them. The one-month trial ships the crawler allow rules, the llms.txt file, and product schema with price and availability on the top sellers. The re-run scan shows the score moved and the fix list shrank. The next month, an assistant answering a question about limited-ingredient dog food names your brand with the current price and the current stock status. You kept the agency, because the trial proved it could do the work. If the trial had ended with a report and no shipped fixes, you would have known in one month, and the switch would have cost a month instead of a contract.

The fundamentals

These mechanics are shared across every engine and covered in full in their own guides:

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers deciding whether your SEO agency can handle AEO. It does not cover moving a retainer from SEO to AEO, which is a separate guide with its own staged plan, and it does not cover the full technical audit that checks every crawler and every page, or the transaction layer that lets an agent complete a purchase. It does not cover how to vet an AEO agency you have never worked with, beyond the trial month described here. Those are separate jobs, and this guide is the map, not the whole trip.

Check your own store now

Run the free scan. One click, no signup, and it shows whether AI crawlers can read your store today: aizii.ai/aeo-scan

Run the free scan

Sources

Note: links marked specific point to the page that supports the claim in this guide. Links marked general docs point to the vendor's general docs section for that topic, not to a page that proves every step. Check the vendor docs for the current path before relying on a menu name or click path in this guide.