An AEO tool and an SEO tool answer different questions. An SEO tool asks how a page ranks in a list of links, and what a shopper clicks. An AEO tool asks whether an AI engine cites the brand in the answer it writes, how often, and who wins the mention instead. The work overlaps, because Google says optimizing for generative AI search is optimizing for the search experience, and thus still SEO, but the measurement is different, and a team that uses one tool for both jobs will miss the other half.
An SEO tool measures a page. An AEO tool measures an answer. That is the difference that matters, and every other difference follows from it.
Where it goes wrong
Teams use the wrong tool for the job, or they treat the two tools as rivals, and then they act on the wrong number.
- An SEO tool is used to judge AI visibility. A page can rank first in classic search and still not be cited in an AI answer, because the answer pulls from a different set of pages, or because the page has the facts but not in a form the answer can quote.
- An AEO tool is used to judge classic search. A brand can be cited in AI answers and still rank poorly in classic search, because the citation came from a guide, a review, or a comparison page, not from the product page itself.
- The two tools are treated as rivals. A team picks one and drops the other, and then loses the measurement that would have explained the change. A drop in AI citations often has an SEO cause, such as a page that stopped being indexed, and a drop in clicks often has an AI cause, such as an answer that satisfied the question without a click.
- Scores are compared across tools. An SEO visibility score and an AEO visibility score are different numbers, built from different data, and they cannot be compared, added, or averaged.
- The tool is blamed for the page. A tool that reports a low citation rate is reporting what the engines do with the pages they can read. Fixing the tool, or switching tools, does not fix the page.
The steps
Step 1. Write down the question each tool answers. The marketer writes one sentence for each tool. An SEO tool answers: where does this page rank, for which query, and what do people click? An AEO tool answers: when a person asks this question to an AI engine, does the answer name the brand, quote the brand, or link to the brand? If a tool cannot answer its own sentence, it is not the right tool for that job.
Step 2. Compare what each tool measures. The marketer lists the measurements. An SEO tool measures rankings, clicks, impressions, and links. An AEO tool measures citations, mention share, sentiment, and accuracy, which is whether the answer states the brand's facts correctly. A tool that only measures rankings cannot tell you about citations, and a tool that only measures citations cannot tell you about rankings.
Step 3. Compare how each tool collects data. The marketer asks how the data is gathered. An SEO tool reads search results pages, crawl data, and link data. An AEO tool runs prompts against AI engines, often daily, and reads the answers. Profound, for example, says it tracks answer engines daily through front end browsers, capturing the response a real user sees. An SEO tool that adds an AI module is still an SEO tool with an extra report, and an AEO tool that adds a rank tracker is still an AEO tool with an extra report. Read the method, not the label.
Step 4. Compare the prompt list with the keyword list. The marketer compares the two lists side by side. The SEO keyword list is built from search queries, such as trail running shoes. The AEO prompt list is built from questions a person asks, such as which trail running shoe fits a wide foot for a wet trail. The prompt list should be longer, more specific, and closer to a shopping decision than the keyword list. If the two lists are the same, the AEO tool is just running keywords through an engine, and it will miss the questions that carry the sale.
Step 5. Compare the next step each tool suggests. The marketer asks what work follows from each report. An SEO tool suggests fixing a title, a link, or a page speed problem. An AEO tool suggests fixing a fact, a comparison, or a missing page that answers a question. Both kinds of work matter, and they are different work, done by different people, on different days.
Step 6. Keep both tools, and read them together. The marketer reads the two reports together once a month. When AI citations fall, check the SEO report first: did the page stop being indexed, did the price change, did the stock change? When clicks fall, check the AEO report first: did an AI answer start satisfying the question, so the shopper never clicked? The two tools explain each other, and neither explains the whole story alone.
The machine-readable piece
Both tools read the same page, and both tools need the same facts in a form a system can read. This is the shape of a Product block with a review summary, using the schema.org vocabulary. The review part is only used when the page visibly shows the reviews and the aggregate rating. Replace the placeholders with your own product facts, and only use values that match the visible page.
<script type="application/ld+json">
{
"@context": "https://schema.org",
"@type": "Product",
"name": "Example Pour Over Coffee Maker",
"image": "https://[yourdomain.com]/images/pour-over-coffee-maker.jpg",
"description": "A pour over coffee maker for a small kitchen, with a glass carafe and a reusable filter.",
"brand": {
"@type": "Brand",
"name": "Example Coffee Brand"
},
"offers": {
"@type": "Offer",
"price": "49.00",
"priceCurrency": "USD",
"availability": "https://schema.org/InStock"
},
"aggregateRating": {
"@type": "AggregateRating",
"ratingValue": "4.6",
"reviewCount": "128"
}
}
</script>
Check the block after you publish it. Open the page and confirm the name, the price, the availability, and the aggregate rating match what the shopper sees. Google says that if you use an aggregate rating, users should be able to see that aggregate rating on the page. Then run the page through the Rich Results Test and fix any error it reports. An SEO tool and an AEO tool will both read the same block, and they will report different things about it, which is the point: the block is the shared fact, and the tools are two different ways of reading it.
What it looks like when it works
Say you run a coffee gear brand, selling pour over makers, grinders, and kettles, with a catalog of about one hundred products. The marketer keeps both tools. The SEO tool shows the pour over maker ranking on the first page for its main query, with steady clicks. The AEO tool shows the brand cited for grinders and kettles, but not for pour over makers, and it shows a competitor cited instead.
The marketer reads the two reports together. The SEO report says the pour over page is indexed and ranking. The AEO report says the answer about pour over makers quotes a comparison page, not the product page, because the product page has no answer to the question which maker suits a small kitchen. The marketer adds that answer to the product page, in plain words, and keeps the Product block the same. The next AEO run shows the brand cited for pour over makers, and the SEO ranking does not move. The two tools measured two different things, and both were right.
The fundamentals
These mechanics are shared across every engine and covered in full in their own guides:
- •The llms.txt format and a complete sample, see our guide to writing a good llms.txt file
- •The markup AI systems read to verify facts, see our product schema guide
- •The complete crawler rule reference, see our robots.txt guide for AI search
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers the difference between AEO tools and SEO tools: what each one measures, how each one collects data, and how to read them together. It does not cover how to pick a single AEO tool, which has its own guide, the full technical audit that checks every crawler and every page, or the transaction layer that lets an agent complete a purchase. It does not cover how to negotiate a vendor contract for either kind of tool. Those are separate jobs, and this guide is the map, not the whole trip.
Check your own store now
Run the free scan. One click, no signup, and it shows whether AI crawlers can read your store today: aizii.ai/aeo-scan
Run the free scanSources
- Google Search Central, Optimizing your website for generative AI features on Google Search (specific): https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide
- Google Search Central, Product structured data (specific): https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/product
- Google Search Central, Review snippet structured data (specific): https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/review-snippet
- Schema.org, Product type (specific): https://schema.org/Product
- Schema.org, AggregateRating type (specific): https://schema.org/AggregateRating
- Profound, The Complete AEO Platform (specific): https://www.tryprofound.com/features
Note: links marked specific point to the page that supports the claim in this guide. Links marked general docs point to the vendor's general docs section for that topic, not to a page that proves every step. Check the vendor docs for the current path before relying on a menu name or click path in this guide.
